Actually has me interested in getting back into the Ethics of Belief literature.
Read more »Recent Ethics of Belief Offerings
New Experiment on Bank Cases
On Certain Doubts, Josh Knobe points to a new study by Wesley Buckwalter on the bank cases. Jason Stanley, Jennifer Nagel, and others join in on the comments.
Read more »“Contextualism, Contrastivism, and X-Phi Surveys”
Keith DeRose posts and discusses a new paper of his on the recent experimental work on contextualism and similar views. He attempts to defend the ordinary language basis for contextualism against empirical results purporting to show that people don't get the expected intuitions in the bank cases.
Read more »Williamson's Mistake Regarding Epistemic Conservatism
In this post I claim that Williamson’s analysis of epistemic conservatism is based on a mistake. Williamson’s mistake in chapter 7, section 6 of Philosophy of Philosophy (POP) involves including the belief that p among one’s reasons for believing that p.
Read more »
Category: Philosophy Tags:
X-Phi Data on Contrasts, Part Two Certain Doubts
Jonathan Schaffer started getting into the X-phi game a while back. Here is a follow up. He has a draft of a paper that he posted a draft of, and he's looking for feedback.
Read more »
Category: Philosophy Tags:
How to Refute Mentalism
Littlejohn gives us an argument against Mentalism
Read more »
Category: Philosophy Tags:
The Unreliability of Naive Introspection
Eric Schwitzgebel posts chapter seven from his book and solicits feedback. Looks like an interesting chapter to me.
Read more »
Category: Philosophy Tags:
A Priori Song
You really might want to listen to this. Posted by Carrie Jenkins over at Long Words Bother Me.
Read more »
Category: Philosophy Tags:
The tautology problem
A long time ago I wrote a not particularly good piece on the tautology problem: that natural selection is merely circular definition. I was just out of being an undergraduate when it was published, so it was at best an undergraduate piece. I have been unsatisfied with it ever since. So I will from time to time post on this. To start, what’s the history?
Read more »
Category: Philosophy Tags:
Intuitions are Nothing Special, or Are They?
This post looks at Williamson's provocative conclusion that it would be better for philosophy if philosophers did not use the term “intuition” in their theorizing. I argue Williamson has not purchased his conclusion because he has misapplied and altogether missed important distinctions that throw into relief parts of his analysis.
Read more »
Category: Philosophy Tags:
Are reasons propositions? John Turri
We believe, disbelieve and suspend judgment based on reasons all the time. I think these reasons are best thought of as mental states of the subject. Other people think that they’re best thought of as propositions.
John Turri challenges the latter view. Great discussion in the comments.

Category: Philosophy Tags:
Williamson on Evidence Neutrality
This blog post looks at Williamson's argument against Evidence Neutrality (EN) in "The Philosophy of Philosophy" chapter 7.
Read more »
Category: Philosophy Tags:
Kornblith Against Reliabilism
In the April edition of Analysis, Hilary Kornblith proposes a reliabilist solution to the bootstrapping problem. I’m going to argue that Kornblith’s proposal, far from solving the bootstrapping problem, in fact makes the problem much harder for the reliabilist to solve. Indeed, I’m going to argue that Kornblith’s considerations give us a way to develop a quick reductio of a certain kind of reliabilism.
Read more »
Category: Philosophy Tags:
Zagzebski on Virtue Acquisition
Today we began studying Sosa’s Epistemology in Professor Kvanvig’s Epistemology seminar. We finished Zagzebski’s Virtues of the Mind last week, and as I made my way through it I noticed some potential problems regarding her views on the acquisition of virtues. In the book Zagzebski outlines a motivation-based virtue theory, which includes an account of intellectual virtues for the purpose of an epistemic application.
Read more »
Category: Philosophy Tags:
Independent Study on Experimental Philosophy
I’m directing an independent study this summer on Experimental Philosophy.
We’re starting with the new reader by Knobe and Nichols. I’ll probably be posting about some of it soon.
So far we’re through the manifesto and the section on cross-cultural differences.
We spent most of our time talking about “Normativity and Epistemic Intuitions”

Category: Philosophy Tags:
Internalist Supervenience for Externalists
Intuitions as Enablers
Continuing the theme of Herman’s recent post, with which I’m in broad agreement, here’s a further discussion of intuitions as evidence.
Alvin Goldman writes:

Category: Philosophy Tags:
Anarchism is to Political Philosophy as Skepticism is to Epistemology
In Nicole Hassoun's NDPR review of Roderick T. Long and Tibor R. Machan (eds.), Anarchism/Minarchism: Is a Government Part of a Free Country?, Ashgate, 2008, we read:
Read more »
Category: Philosophy Tags:
Williamson and Conceptual Analysis
I have some nascent worries about Williamson’s critique of epistemological analyticity in Ch. 4 of The Philosophy of Philosophy (Blackwell, 2007) that I’d appreciate some feedback on.
Sufficiency and decisiveness
It seems from what Williamson says in Section 8 of Ch. 4 that he holds that his Peter and Stephen cases establish not only 1t and 1l, but also something like 2t and 2l:
(1t) Grasping the thought every vixen is a vixen is not sufficient for knowing every vixen is a vixen.

Category: Philosophy Tags:
What is Recent Philosophy?
There is, I think, something of a standard history of 20th Century English-speaking philosophy, at least through 1980. The broad outlines are fairly familiar.
Read more »
Category: Philosophy Tags:
Recent Tops in Current Category
- 3Why We Should Teach Philosophy to Children
- 2Oxford Studies in Epistemology Vol. 3
- 2Using Twitter to Map America's Mood
- 2Scientific Fraud
- 2New regulations proposed for for-profit colleges
- 2New Copyright Ruling Is Good News for Higher Ed
- 2Western Diet Link to ADHD, Australian Study Finds
- 2The Big Fat Lie of The Author Bio
- 2Administrative Glut
- 2Napster for Books
